Assignment #3
Physics 274
Due: Wednesday 12 October 2011
This assignment deals with qualitative and quantitative effects of nuclear explosions,
based on documented eyewitness accounts of the Hiroshima attack. The main
purpose is for you to get a sense of the destructive power and damage scale
of these devices as compared to convention weapons. But moreover, it serves to drive home
the fact that
people actually can survive a nuclear attack (even if they're extremely
close to the blast).
Provide a detailed written answer to all questions! Do not answer
with just a "yes" or "no", but justify your reasoning for saying so. Answers
that are too short will be dealt with accordingly!
Your tasks are as follows:
- On this website you will find The Voice of Hibakusha, which contains
a set of 14 eyewitness accounts of the Hiroshima bomb explosion. These individuals
were located at various distances from the hypocenter, one as close as
300 m (1000 ft) and another as far as 5 km (3 miles). Naturally, each
account is different, depending on how far away they were.
Read all 14 accounts, and assemble a list of the reported
effects (both to structures and people), and how they vary with distance from
ground zero (the hypocenter).
Look for commonalities between the accounts, and highlight any which you
feel are important.
Specifically, discuss the testimony of the individuals who were closest and
furthest from the blast.
You may present your results in a table of the form (in order of INCREASING
distance from ground zero!):
| Distance | Effects |
| 300 m | itemize effects |
| 700 m | itemize effects |
| . . . . . . . |
[FYI: 1 m = 3.33 feet; 1 km = 0.62 miles]
- Based on your results, discuss what you think the effects of a similar
sized nuclear blast (about 15 kt) would be on LMU/Westchester, assuming the
hypocenter is located at the Seaver Science Center (I've made some powerful
enemies...). Print out this map of LMU,
and indicate equivalent distances to those listed in
your table (draw circles centered on campus). The map scale is
indicated, so the entire width corresponds to about 7 km (i.e. the
maximum circle you can draw will have a radius of 3.5 km).
Now consider the following questions:
- (a) Would the University (people and buildings) survive the attack?
- (b) About how far would you have to be from the hypocenter to
survive the initial blast, based on the testimony?
- (c) Do you think the bomb would have identical effects as those
described by the testimonies you've read? Think carefully!
- (d) Little Boy exploded at an altitude of about 1800 ft (550 m).
How do you think the size of the affected areas would change if it had
detonated at a lower altitude? That is, discuss how you think burst height
affects the damage area.
Note: After you finish you might want to go for a drive (or bike ride,
or leisurely run) and see exactly how big the circle radii are, to get
a real sense of magnitude of the effects.